A Sour Kraut

"It is worse still to be ignorant of your ignorance." ~Saint Jerome

My Photo
Name:
Location: Bozeman, MT, United States

Tuesday, July 12, 2005

Interesting Post @ Leithart.com

Here is an interesting post left by Peter Leithart on his blog site today. His biblical interpretation of this passage kept bringing to mind a picture of Homer's great war hero Odysseus: One of the mightiest, fiercest men to fight in the Trojan War, and still portrayed as one of the greatest husbands and fathers too.

Perpetual War
"According to Deuteronomy 20, any man who had built a house, planted a vineyard, or married a wife without enjoying their benefits and joys was excused from military service. While it was certainly possible for a 20-year-old Israelite to be unmarried and propertyless, it would seem that the military was largely made up of men who already had these benefits of peace. I base this on the supposition that men would be entering on an independent adulthood at 20, the same age they became eligible for military service. Also, I'm assuming that Israelite ages of marriage were comparable to other ancient civilizations; Roman girls, for instance, were considered marriageable at 12 and adults at 14, at which age men would begin to call them "domina." Thus, Israel's army would largely consist of men who already had some experience of the benefits of adult life in peacetime.
This has important effects on the makeup and psychology of the military. First, the men going to war had some sense of why they were fighting and what they were defending. Second, home, vineyard, and wife provided a triple anchor that kept an Israelite warrior from getting too attached to the battlefield. This was particularly important in the ancient world, when war was for some men was life, not an irritating interruption of life.
Nearly 99,000 of the total 281,000 members of the Air Force are single, and about 112,000 of the total number are under 25. (See www.afpc.randolph.af.mil/demographics/ReportSearch.asp.) What kind of incentives are we building into our military by sending twentysomethings with no life at home and nothing to lose into battle? "

8 Comments:

Blogger Andrea said...

That's an interesting thought, Brian. I've never really thought of it that way. It always breaks my heart to see photos of videos of men and women going off to war and leaving their tearful families behind. I wonder at the contrast of attitudes between a soldier with loved ones at home and a single solitary soldier with nothing really to lose and having no one waiting at home. Does the former fight harder and smarter and the latter fight more recklessly? I don't know, but, interesting to think about..

7/22/05, 9:15 AM  
Blogger Brian said...

I am only speculating Andrea, but I would assume that a man with a family and a home will fight harder to stay alive; which should mean more courageously and more wisely. A married man also knows much more about having the responsibility of protecting others. One of the thoughts I liked the most in this post though, is his point that a married man will also understand war as an "irritating interruption of life" instead of a "way of life".

7/22/05, 3:47 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It seems to make sense to me that if you have somebody/something to fight for, then you will fight harder, especially if that person/idea is very near and dear. How much does it matter what the end result of the war will be? Say, if we win we get more land for our country, or if we win we drive the enemy away from our family, or if we win we make someone's life that we do not know better?

7/25/05, 11:30 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wanted to make one other statement based on a post a while ago regarding "home".

I think the Bible gives us the best answer to what makes a home. Genesis tells of the institution of the family established with Adam and Eve. From then on all people are in a family, until they get married "24Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and they shall become one flesh." Each new family is started by a covenant vow, an oath. Each of these little families (covenant communities) has to commune/live together some where and that place is the home, just a the larger Christian, covenant community has to commune/live somewhere, that place being a church.
So just as the church isn't a church without people in it, so a house isn't a home without a family in it.
Until I have a family, my home is in my parents house.

7/25/05, 11:50 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wanted to make one other statement based on a post a while ago regarding "home".

I think the Bible gives us the best answer to what makes a home. Genesis tells of the institution of the family established with Adam and Eve. From then on all people are in a family, until they get married "24Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and they shall become one flesh." Each new family is started by a covenant vow, an oath. Each of these little families (covenant communities) has to commune/live together some where and that place is the home, just a the larger Christian, covenant community has to commune/live somewhere, that place being a church.
So just as the church isn't a church without people in it, so a house isn't a home without a family in it.
Until I have a family, my home is in my parents house.

7/25/05, 11:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wanted to make one other statement based on a post a while ago regarding "home".

I think the Bible gives us the best answer to what makes a home. Genesis tells of the institution of the family established with Adam and Eve. From then on all people are in a family, until they get married "24Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and they shall become one flesh." Each new family is started by a covenant vow, an oath. Each of these little families (covenant communities) has to commune/live together some where and that place is the home, just a the larger Christian, covenant community has to commune/live somewhere, that place being a church.
So just as the church isn't a church without people in it, so a house isn't a home without a family in it.
Until I have a family, my home is in my parents house.

7/25/05, 11:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I wanted to make one other statement based on a post a while ago regarding "home".

I think the Bible gives us the best answer to what makes a home. Genesis tells of the institution of the family established with Adam and Eve. From then on all people are in a family, until they get married "24Therefore a man shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife, and they shall become one flesh." Each new family is started by a covenant vow, an oath. Each of these little families (covenant communities) has to commune/live together some where and that place is the home, just a the larger Christian, covenant community has to commune/live somewhere, that place being a church.
So just as the church isn't a church without people in it, so a house isn't a home without a family in it.
Until I have a family, my home is in my parents house.

7/25/05, 11:51 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

sorry, i couldn't get the publish comment button to work. guess I pushed it too many times.

7/25/05, 11:52 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home